A good complaint is clear, factual and easy to act on. We analyse what makes a supermarket complaint effective, and what to do when the first answer is not enough.
Key Finding
A good complaint is clear, factual and easy to act on.
What makes a complaint effective
An effective complaint does three things. It says what happened, it says when and where it happened, and it says what the shopper would like to happen next. A complaint that does those three things clearly is easy for a customer service team to act on. A complaint that does not is likely to generate a request for more information, which delays the resolution.
The tone matters too. A complaint does not need to be angry to be effective, and anger can make it harder to read. A clear, factual account of what went wrong, with the evidence to support it, is more likely to reach a resolution than a complaint that is long on feeling and short on detail.
That is not to say feeling does not matter. A shopper who has been let down has every right to say so. The point is that feeling should sit alongside the facts, not instead of them, so the team can understand both what happened and how it affected the shopper.
What to include
Every complaint should include the basic facts: the store, the date and, if relevant, the time of the visit or the delivery. It should include the product details if the complaint is about a product, and the order number if it is about an online order. It should say what went wrong in plain terms, and it should say what outcome the shopper is seeking.
Evidence helps. A photograph of a faulty or damaged product, a copy of the receipt, or a screenshot of an order confirmation can all support a complaint and speed the process. Evidence should be attached where the channel allows it, and described clearly where it does not.
Choosing the channel
The channel matters for a complaint, because it affects the record. A written complaint, through an online form or email, creates a record from the start, and both sides can refer back to it. That record is useful if the complaint needs to be followed up or escalated, and it is the main reason the online route is often the better choice for a complaint.
A phone complaint can be faster, particularly for a problem that needs a conversation, but it is worth noting the date, the time, the name of the person spoken to, and any reference number given. Without those notes, a phone complaint leaves no record for the shopper to refer to later.
An in-store complaint suits a problem that can be shown, such as a faulty product brought back to the store with the receipt. It is the fastest route for a simple return or refund, but it is less suited to a complex complaint that needs investigation, where a written record will serve the shopper better.
An effective complaint does three things.
How the stores handle complaints
Each store handles complaints through its own customer service operation, and the routes are set out in the store guides. The Tesco customer service, Sainsbury's customer service, Morrisons customer service and Waitrose customer service guides each explain how to contact that store, and the same principles apply to a complaint at any of them.
For the online-only operation, the Ocado customer service guide explains the phone and online routes, and for the leaner operation, the Lidl customer service guide explains how its central team works. M&S, with the widest product range, is covered in the M&S customer service guide.
For the full comparison, the supermarket customer service guide sets the contact routes for every major store side by side. A complaint should be directed through the route that suits the problem, not simply through the first contact option the shopper finds.
What to expect after you complain
A simple problem, such as a faulty product or a missing item from a delivery, can often be resolved in that first exchange, whether by phone, online or in store.
More complex complaints take longer. A problem may need to be investigated, a product may need to be inspected, or a complaint may need to be passed to a specialist team. A reasonable wait is part of that process, and the store should keep the shopper informed about the progress of the investigation.
If no reply arrives within the time the store indicated, or if the reply does not address the problem, the next step is to follow up. A follow-up should refer to the original complaint, the date it was made, and any reference number given, so the team can find the case without starting again.
Escalation: when the first answer is not enough
If a complaint is not resolved at the first contact, escalation is the usual next step. That means asking for the complaint to be reviewed by a senior member of the team, or for it to be passed to a specialist complaints team. It is a normal part of the process, not a confrontation, and it should be requested in the same clear, factual tone as the original complaint.
Escalation works best when the shopper can show the history of the complaint: the date of the original contact, the channel used, any reference numbers, and the replies received. Keeping a record of each contact, with dates and reference numbers, makes that history easy to present.
If escalation within the store does not resolve the problem, there are further routes, including consumer advice services and, for some kinds of problem, an ombudsman or regulator. Those routes are outside the scope of this guide, but they exist, and a shopper who has kept a clear record of the complaint will be in a stronger position to use them.
Common mistakes to avoid
The most common mistake is to complain without the details the team needs. A complaint that does not say which store, which date or which product is about will generate a request for more information, and that delays the resolution. A few minutes spent gathering the details before making contact will save more time later.
The second mistake is to use the wrong channel. A complex complaint made in store, where it cannot be recorded properly, or an urgent problem raised by email, where it will wait for a reply, are both likely to take longer than they need to. Matching the channel to the problem is the simplest way to avoid that.
The third mistake is to give up too early. A complaint that stalls is not necessarily a complaint that has failed. A follow-up, with the reference number and the history of the contact, will often move a stalled complaint forward, and escalation is available when a follow-up does not.