There is no single cheapest supermarket delivery, because the answer changes with order size, frequency and timing, and the charging structure matters more than any one headline charge.
Key Finding
No single delivery service is cheapest for every household.
Why cheapest is the wrong first question
Shoppers often ask which supermarket delivery is cheapest as if the answer were a fixed ranking. In practice the ranking moves. A service that is cheapest for a large weekly shop can be expensive for a small top up, and a service that is cheap for an off peak slot can be costly at a popular time. The reason is that retailers charge for delivery in different ways, and the structure of the charge matters as much as the amount. A flat charge, a charge that varies by slot, a minimum spend, and a subscription or delivery pass all produce different results for different shoppers.
The useful question is therefore not which service is cheapest in general, but which service is cheapest for a particular pattern of shopping. A household that orders once a week in large orders needs a different answer from a household that orders twice a week in small orders, and both need a different answer from a household that orders only when something runs out. This guide compares the structures, not the amounts, so that a shopper can work out which structure fits their own pattern.
How delivery charges are structured
Delivery charges generally fall into a few patterns. Some retailers charge a fee for each delivery, with the fee varying by the time of the slot. Off peak slots cost less than peak slots, because the retailer wants to spread demand across the day. Some retailers waive the charge above a minimum spend, which rewards larger orders. Some offer a delivery pass or subscription, where the shopper pays regularly and then pays little or nothing per delivery.
Minimum spends and their effect
A minimum spend is the smallest order a retailer will deliver. It exists because delivering a very small order costs almost as much as delivering a large one, in driver time, fuel and picking labour, while bringing in far less revenue. A minimum spend protects the retailer from that imbalance, but it changes the shopper's behaviour. A shopper who only needs a few items may add items they do not need in order to reach the threshold, which defeats the purpose of a small top up order.
The effect of a minimum spend depends on the shopper. For a weekly shop, it is rarely a problem, because the order is well above the threshold. For a top up shop, it can be the deciding factor. A retailer with a low threshold suits top up shopping. A retailer with a high threshold suits weekly shopping. A shopper who does both may need two services, or may accept that top up shopping is better done in store.
A minimum spend is the smallest order a retailer will deliver.
Delivery passes and regular ordering
A delivery pass is a regular payment that covers delivery charges for a period, usually a month or a longer term. It can be good value for a household that orders every week, because the cost per delivery falls with each order. It can be poor value for a household that orders once a month, because the pass costs the same whether it is used once or four times. The break even point depends on how often the household orders and on what the pass costs, so the calculation is personal.
Passes also vary in their terms. Some cover every slot, including peak times. Others cover only off peak slots, or exclude certain days. Some can be paused or cancelled easily. Others tie the shopper in for a fixed period. A shopper considering a pass should check those terms, not just the headline, because a pass that excludes the slots the household actually uses is not a saving at all.
Slots, timing and hidden costs
The time of the slot affects the charge at many retailers, and it affects the cost in less obvious ways too. An off peak slot may be cheaper, but it may require someone to be at home during the working day, which is not possible for every household. A peak slot may cost more, but it fits around work and school. The cheapest slot on paper is not the cheapest slot in practice if it requires taking time off work or rearranging the day.
There are also costs that do not appear in the delivery charge. A substitution that replaces a cheaper item with a dearer one adds cost. A missing item that has to be bought separately adds a trip. A delivery that arrives when nobody is home and has to be rearranged adds delay. The delivery slots a shopper chooses, and the substitution preferences they set, both affect the real cost of the order, not just the delivery charge.
Comparing services without a price list
A fair comparison of delivery services needs to hold the pattern of shopping constant. Compare the same order size, the same frequency, and the same slot time across retailers, and the differences in structure become clear. One retailer may be cheaper for a large weekly order at an off peak time. Another may be cheaper for a small order at a peak time. Neither result proves that one retailer is cheaper in general. It proves that one retailer is cheaper for that pattern.
Best supermarket delivery is a related question, but it is not the same as cheapest. The best service for a shopper may cost more, because it offers a wider range, a narrower delivery window, or better availability. The cheapest service may be the best for a shopper who values cost above all else. The two guides answer different questions, and a shopper should be clear which question they are asking before they compare.
What to check before choosing
Before choosing a delivery service on cost, a shopper should check four things. First, the charging structure: flat, variable by slot, waived above a threshold, or pass based. Second, the minimum spend, and whether their usual order clears it. Third, the slot availability in their area at the times they can be at home. Fourth, the substitution and refund policy, because that affects the final cost of the order. How supermarket delivery works explains the process behind those policies, and it is worth reading before committing to a regular service.
The cheapest service for one household is often not the cheapest for the next, and that is not a failure of comparison. It is a sign that the retailers have designed their services for different shoppers. The household that orders little and often, the household that orders once a week, and the household that orders only in an emergency are three different customers, and each will find a different service cheapest.